Bahamian Stew Fish with a Vegan Twist: Cooking with Hearts of Palm

Its Bahamian Stew Fish with a Vegan Twist: Cooking with Hearts of Palm for the perfect substitute for this amazing Bahamian traditional dish.  In every Bahamian home, stew fish is more than a meal—it’s a memory. It’s the scent of Saturday morning, the promise of a good meal after a long week, and a dish that brings the family to the table. Traditionally made with fresh snapper, browned flour, bold seasonings, and often paired with grits or Johnny cake, Bahamian stew fish is one of our national treasures. But what if we could enjoy all that richness and flavor—with none of the fish?

BAHAMIAN STEW FISH

As the Bahamian Vegan, I’ve made it my mission to honor our island roots while creating recipes that nourish the body and soul. Today, I’m excited to share a wholesome, plant-based version of this beloved dish using hearts of palm as the star.

What Is Hearts of Palm?

If you’ve never cooked with hearts of palm, you’re in for a treat. Harvested from the inner core of certain palm trees, this vegetable is tender, slightly tangy, and has a texture uncannily similar to flaked fish or crab meat. When seasoned and simmered in our rich, island-style gravy, it becomes the perfect substitute for snapper or grouper in this veganized version of stew fish.

Hearts of palm are low in calories, high in fiber, and a great source of iron, zinc, potassium, and vitamin C. For those managing cholesterol or trying to reduce inflammation, this plant-based protein alternative offers all the satisfaction of seafood without the saturated fat or environmental impact.

A Taste of Tradition—Without Compromise

I remember growing up on the island, the kitchen buzzing with the sounds of onions sizzling, thyme snapping, and tomatoes bubbling in a cast iron pot. My mother would brown her flour just right, adding depth and color to the stew. She’d add the fish, pour in the water, and let the flavors marry into something magical.

Now, as a certified nutritionist, plant-based chef, and wellness coach, I wanted to recreate that feeling—but with a twist. This vegan version stays true to the seasoning base of the original, but we’ve made a few swaps that transform it into a whole-food, plant-powered option.

Why Veganize Bahamian Classics?

Our culture is rich with flavors, but many traditional dishes are also rich in saturated fats, animal products, and processed ingredients that don’t always support long-term health. As lifestyle diseases like diabetes, hypertension, and heart disease continue to rise—especially in the Caribbean—it’s time we rethink how we cook, without sacrificing how we connect.

By replacing the fish with hearts of palm, we preserve the nostalgic taste of our stew while opening the door to better digestion, lower inflammation, and more compassion toward our bodies and our environment. This is food that heals and honors.

Other stews you may enjoy:

Stewed Pigeon Peas

Jamaican Stew Peas

Easy Lentil Stew

Cooking with Purpose

As we make these changes in the kitchen, it’s more than just a dietary shift—it’s a spiritual one, too. When I prepare meals now, I ask: “Is this something that will fuel my body for purpose?” The Bible says in 1 Corinthians 10:31, “Whether therefore ye eat, or drink, or whatsoever ye do, do all to the glory of God.”

Eating plant-based isn’t just a health decision; for me, it’s a ministry. It’s about respecting the temple God gave me and using it to do His work with energy and joy.

Let’s Talk Taste

Now let me assure you—this dish does not taste like you’re missing anything. The umami from the browned flour and tomato paste, the depth from the sautéed vegetables, and the subtle sea-like texture of the hearts of palm come together in a satisfying, soulful stew.

You can take it even further by pairing this with boiled plantains, cassava, or a scoop of grits. For Sabbath mornings, this has become a staple on my table—and it surprises even the most skeptical meat-eaters!

Final Thoughts

Bahamian stew fish with hearts of palm is more than just a recipe. It’s a celebration of where we come from, and a step toward where we’re going—a life of wellness, vibrancy, and balance. Whether you’re on a weight loss journey, reversing diabetes, or simply exploring new flavors, this dish is a beautiful way to reconnect with culture while walking in health.

Let this be a reminder that “something better” is not about restriction—it’s about restoration. Restoration of energy, of joy in eating, of reverence for our bodies, and ultimately, of our connection to God through every bite we take.

⸻

Ready to try it? Tag me on Instagram or share your creations using #TheBahamianVegan and let me know how your family enjoyed it. Let’s keep making our traditions work for us, not against us.